Your biggest competition might not be the business across the street selling the same thing as you. It might be the habit your customers haven’t broken yet, or the workaround they’ve built to get by. That’s the thing about understanding direct vs indirect competitors — it changes how you look at business.
This post breaks down the differences between direct and indirect competitors, why both matter for your strategy, and how to build a complete picture of your competitive landscape — so you can make smarter decisions with the information you already have.
Direct vs indirect competitors defined
Before you can act on your competitive landscape, you need to know who’s actually in it. The most straightforward way to divide the playing field is into two categories: direct competitors and indirect competitors.
A direct competitor is any business that sells a similar product or service to the same audience you’re targeting. If you run a local bookshop, your direct competitors are other bookshops — online and off. They’re going after the same customer, with a comparable offer, in the same market.
An indirect competitor is subtler. These are businesses (or behaviors) that solve the same underlying problem your customer has, but in a different way. The local bookshop’s indirect competitors might include libraries, podcast apps, or even social media — anything that satisfies the same need for entertainment, learning, or escapism without selling a single book.
Why it matters for growing businesses
The differences between direct and indirect competitors aren’t just academic — they shape how you allocate budget, how you position your brand, and where your next customer is coming from.
Direct competitor strategy: When you understand your direct rivals, you can sharpen your pricing, refine your messaging, and identify the features or service areas where you genuinely have an edge. You’re speaking to the same audience, so the contest is often about clarity — why you, over them.
Indirect competitor strategy: With indirect competitors, the fight is often upstream. You’re not just competing with an alternative offer — you’re competing with inertia, habit, or a different category altogether. Your job here is to help customers understand why your solution is worth making a change.
Ignoring either type leaves a hole in your strategy. You could start with a competitor analysis, and here are a few ways to do just that.
How to identify your direct and indirect competitors
The best place to start is with your own customers. Think about what problem they’re trying to solve — not what product they’re buying. Once you know the problem, you can map out every way it could be solved.
Start with search and social
Type in the exact phrases your customers use to find you. The businesses appearing alongside you in the results are your most direct competitors. The adjacent content — tutorials, advice articles, DIY guides — hints at your indirect ones.
Talk to your customers
Ask new customers what they were doing before they found you, and what else they considered. This is some of the most valuable competitive intelligence you can collect, and it costs nothing. You can use a customer relationship management (CRM) system to draft, launch, and log these surveys so nothing gets lost, and patterns surface across your team over time.
Run a structured competitor analysis
Once you’ve built your list, a formal competitor analysis helps you organize what you know — pricing, positioning, product gaps, and customer sentiment — into a format your whole team can act on. From there, tools like a strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats (SWOT) analysis let you assess your own position relative to both direct and indirect rivals.
If you’re working with Salesforce, you can learn how to track competitors directly on Trailhead, the free online learning platform for all businesses. From there, you can take deep dives into marketing strategies, using AI to grow your business and so much more.
Using competitor differences to sharpen your positioning
Knowing who your competitors are is only useful if you do something with it. The goal isn’t to copy what’s working for others — it’s to find the white space they’ve left open.
When you understand competitor differences clearly, you can:
Identify unmet needs: Direct competitors may be serving the same audience, but they’re not serving it perfectly. Look for the complaints, the workarounds, and the service gaps your customers mention. That’s your opening.
Reframe your value: Speak to the outcome, not the tool. Have you been bragging about your product or service without showcasing value? Don’t worry if you have, you’re not alone, a lot of businesses do. Try sharing outcomes instead of features.
Stay ahead of market shifts: Indirect competitors often become direct ones. The music streaming service that was once a fringe alternative is now the whole industry. Keeping tabs on both types means you’re less likely to be caught off guard. This business intelligence strategy guide covers how to build the data habits that keep you current.
How to track competitor differences over time
Your competitive landscape doesn’t stand still, and neither should your analysis. A one-time audit is a good start, but businesses that stay sharp treat competitor tracking as an ongoing process, not a quarterly chore they dread.
Here’s what a sustainable rhythm looks like:
- Set a regular review cadence: Monthly or quarterly check-ins — depending on how fast your market moves — keep your view updated without becoming a full-time job.
- Centralize what you learn: Every customer conversation, sales objection, and lost deal holds competitive intelligence. A CRM system captures it all in one place so your team’s collective knowledge compounds, rather than disappearing when someone leaves a call.
- Watch for indirect competitors moving upstream: If a substitute solution starts adding features that overlap with your core offer, your indirect competitor is becoming a direct one. That’s your signal to act.
How AI can help with competitive intelligence
AI is turning competitive intelligence from a manual research project into a real-time strategic advantage. Instead of losing hours to data entry and fragmented searches, lean teams can now use AI to surface patterns that used to be invisible.
With AI agents, your CRM becomes a proactive partner in spotting market shifts. These agents work autonomously to handle routine data tasks and analyze customer records, ensuring your team spends less time chasing information and more time acting on it.
For growing businesses, Salesforce Suites provides the foundation by centralizing all your data in one connected platform. This unified view allows employee agents to help you with competitive research, such as:
- Automated analysis: Employee agents can summarize call logs, research accounts, and flag common competitive objections so you can refine your pitch instantly.
- Faster response times: By automating routine research and record updates, AI frees your team to focus on high-value strategy and deepening customer trust.
- Scalable intelligence: Further extend these capabilities via AgentExchange, integrating third-party tools that track market trends directly within the CRM.
Get the Guide to AI for Small Business
Save time, automate tasks, and set your team up for success with this free guide to all things AI and business.
Direct vs indirect competitors: Build the full picture with Salesforce
Understanding the differences between direct and indirect competitors gives you something most businesses are missing: A complete view of the competitive field. The companies that grow aren’t always the ones with the biggest budget — they’re the ones who know where to look, and who make a habit of looking often.
Get started with Salesforce for free or activate Foundations to try out Agentforce today.
AI supported the writers and editors who created this article.
What is the main difference between direct and indirect competitors?
Direct competitors sell similar products or services to the same target audience. Indirect competitors solve the same underlying customer problem but through a different product, service, or category — they’re competing for the same outcome, not the same shelf space.
Why should small businesses care about indirect competitors?
Indirect competitors are often the ones you don’t see coming. A customer who cancels because they “just don’t need it anymore” has often found an indirect alternative — a habit, a workaround, or a different category entirely. Understanding indirect rivals helps you build a pitch that addresses the full range of alternatives your customer is weighing.
How often should I do a competitive analysis?
Markets shift faster than most annual reviews can capture. Aim for a quarterly check-in at minimum, with a more thorough review once or twice a year. You can read more about building that process in the guide to competitor analysis for small businesses.
Can a CRM help me track my competitors?
Yes — and it’s one of the most underused applications of a CRM for growing businesses. When your team logs customer conversations, sales objections, and lost deal reasons in one place, competitive patterns emerge naturally. You can also use Salesforce to build structured competitor tracking workflows that keep your whole team aligned on what you know.
What happens if an indirect competitor becomes a direct one?
It happens more often than you’d think — and it’s usually faster than expected. The best defense is keeping your indirect competitor list active and watching for product or positioning changes that bring them closer to your space.
